| 100% | OLEANNA | 7 | Mamet play revived on Broadway in 2009 |
| 64% | ANGELSINAMERICA | 15 | Two-part Tony-winning play revived on Broadway in 2018 |
| 47% | SPEEDTHEPL | 10 | Mamet play in which Madonna made her Broadway debut |
| 39% | FUNNYGIRL | 9 | Fanny Brice musical revived on Broadway |
| 38% | AHWILDERNESS | 12 | Comedy that debuted on Broadway in 1933 |
| 38% | AUDRA | 5 | Singer McDonald who played Billie Holiday on Broadway in 2014 |
| 37% | HAIR | 4 | "Love-Rock Musical" that opened on Broadway in 1968 |
| 36% | SIS | 3 | Actress who organized the Trans March on Broadway in 2021 |
| 36% | LEAR | 4 | Shakespearean king portrayed on Broadway in 2019 by Glenda Jackson |
| 36% | MARTINSHORT | 11 | "Three Amigos" actor who plays a Broadway director/true crime podcaster on "Only Murders in the Building" (2 wds.) |
| 36% | LOOT | 4 | 1965 Joe Orton stage play that ran on Broadway in 1968 |
| 36% | THEANATOMIST | 12 | 1930 stage play by James Bridie produced on Broadway in 1932 |
| 36% | ISHEDEAD | 8 | 1898 play by Mark Twain that opened on Broadway in 2007 |
| 36% | EASYVIRTUE | 10 | Noel Coward play that opened on Broadway, New York, in 1925 |
| 36% | HAIR | 4 | American Tribal Love Rock Musical that opened on Broadway in 1968 |
| 36% | LEVI | 4 | Actor Zachary who debuted on Broadway in 2013's "First Date" |
| 36% | REBA | 4 | Singer McEntire who starred on Broadway in "Annie Get Your Gun" |
| 36% | HAIR | 4 | 'American Tribal Love Rock Musical' that opened on Broadway in 1968 |
| 36% | HAIR | 4 | American Tribal Love Rock Musical which opened on Broadway in 1968 |
| 35% | PLOT | 4 | This thickens, on Broadway (of a play) |
| 35% | FELA | 4 | 2009 Broadway musical set in Nigeria |
| 34% | SETS | 4 | Scenery in Broadway plays |
| 34% | JONATHAN | 8 | Role played by Boris Karloff on Broadway and Raymond Massey in the film |
| 34% | ANA | 3 | Comedian Gasteyer who was on Broadway in 2024's "Once Upon a Mattress" |
| 34% | AIDA | 4 | Opera that was adapted into a musical that opened on Broadway in 2000 |
| 34% | EVITA | 5 | Broadway role played by Madonna in film |
| 34% | TABOO | 5 | Stage musical by Boy George and Kevan Frost that opened on Broadway in 2003 |
| 34% | EASYVIRTUE | 10 | Noel Coward stage play that opened on Broadway, New York, in 1925 |
| 34% | EASYVIRTUE | 10 | Noel Coward stage play that opened on Broadway, New York in 1925 |
| 33% | PARTYDOWN | 9 | 2009 Adam Scott show newly revived in 2023 |