| 100% | TROPE | 5 | Mirror scare in a horror movie, e.g. |
| 54% | TROPE | 5 | Evil clown in a horror film, e.g. |
| 52% | BOO | 3 | Greeting in a horror movie? |
| 52% | DOOR | 4 | Squeaker in a horror movie? |
| 52% | RUN | 3 | Command in a horror movie |
| 51% | PDA | 3 | Making out in a movie theater, e.g. |
| 51% | ELM | 3 | Street in a horror movie franchise |
| 51% | IMAGE | 5 | Face in a mirror, e.g. |
| 51% | ELM | 3 | Street name in a horror movie franchise |
| 51% | VOODOODOLL | 10 | One getting stuck in a horror movie |
| 51% | GORE | 4 | Blood and guts, in a horror movie |
| 51% | EERIE | 5 | Like silence in a horror movie, say |
| 51% | NONO | 4 | Talking in a movie theater, e.g. |
| 51% | PDA | 3 | Kissing in a movie theater, e.g. |
| 50% | KNOB | 4 | It may turn slowly in a horror movie |
| 49% | ELM | 3 | Freddy Krueger's street, in a horror movie franchise |
| 49% | ELM | 3 | Tree name that is also in a horror movie name |
| 48% | CAMEO | 5 | Stan Lee appearance in a Marvel movie, e.g. |
| 46% | ACTIONHERO | 10 | One-man wrecking crew in a movie, e.g. |
| 46% | GASP | 4 | Audible reaction to a jump-scare in a horror movie |
| 45% | ITSALIVE | 8 | Cry in a grade-B horror movie |
| 45% | ELM | 3 | "Street" in a popular horror movie title |
| 45% | ELM | 3 | Tree in a series of horror movie titles |
| 44% | BOOGEYMAN | 9 | 2005 horror movie about a monster in the closet |
| 43% | KEKE | 4 | Portrayer of Emerald in a 2022 Jordan Peele horror movie |
| 43% | OMEN | 4 | "The First ___" (upcoming horror movie involving a church in Rome) |
| 43% | GORY | 4 | Like a graphic scene in a horror movie |
| 43% | STAPLE | 6 | Jump scares, in horror movies |
| 43% | YETI | 4 | Monster who is the "Snow Beast" in a 2011 horror movie |
| 42% | ONLINE | 6 | In a chat room, e.g. |