| 100% | MUSIAL | 6 | One of three men to play in 24 All-Star Games, with Aaron and Mays |
| 49% | TITLE | 5 | With 66-Across, images played in silent films, and what one might use to play the games in the first parts of the answers to the starred clues? |
| 39% | MAYS | 4 | Baseball Hall of Famer Willie who played in 24 All-Star Games |
| 38% | BOJACKSON | 9 | Only athlete to play in an MLB All-Star Game and an NFL Pro Bowl |
| 37% | ROOM | 4 | One of three found in each answer to a starred clue |
| 37% | TED | 3 | Danson who played one of the three men in "Three Men and a Baby" |
| 37% | MAYS | 4 | #24 who played in 24 All-Star Games |
| 36% | WATER | 5 | *___ balloon fight, snowball fight alternative for Christmas in July ... and a game one might play with friends in the backyard |
| 36% | SLOTH | 5 | One of three living mammals in the superorder Xenarthra, along with the armadillo and anteater |
| 33% | THE | 3 | With 71-Across and each answer to a starred clue, all of it |
| 33% | AFEW | 4 | Quantity of “Good Men” in an Aaron Sorkin play and film |
| 33% | ALPHABETIZATION | 15 | One way of ordering things, like all the consonants in rows three, six and nine |
| 32% | OUT | 3 | One of three in a triple play |
| 32% | SCISSORS | 8 | One of three choices in a kids' game |
| 32% | DENEB | 5 | One of three stars in the Summer Triangle |
| 32% | LEO | 3 | One of three fire signs, with Aries and Sagittarius |
| 32% | ACT | 3 | One of three in "Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead" |
| 32% | REF | 3 | One of three in an NBA game, for short |
| 32% | INA | 3 | With 60-Down, on one's game ... and hint to the start of this puzzle's longest answers |
| 32% | SHAKYGROUND | 11 | With "on," not strong, as an argument ... and what might cause the ends of answers to starred clues? |
| 32% | BULLET | 6 | Bit of ammo that one might want to "dodge" and has a "bull" in its name |
| 32% | HOMER | 5 | One of sixty-two for Aaron Judge in 2022, or one of seven hundred and three for Albert Pujols in his career, familiarly |
| 31% | DIE | 3 | One of three used in a game of Cee-lo |
| 31% | IAMB | 4 | One of three in "To be or not to be" |
| 31% | EDGEWISE | 8 | One way to get a word in ... and an aural hint to a feature of the starred clues' answers |
| 31% | TEAMPLAYERS | 11 | Ones unconcerned with individual achievements ... or what both words in the answers to the starred clues are examples of |
| 31% | SETLIST | 7 | Itemized concert songs in playing order ... and what all the words in answers to starred clues comprise |
| 31% | MAGUS | 5 | Any one of three wise men in the Bible |
| 31% | WILL | 4 | I was one of the men in "Men in Black" and I'm also father to two singers |
| 31% | ROSE | 4 | Pete ___, former baseball player who is the all-time MLB leader in hits and number of games played |