| 100% | MUSIAL | 6 | Seven-time N.L. batting champ |
| 83% | KINER | 5 | Seven-time N.L. homer champ |
| 79% | KINER | 5 | Seven-time N.L. home run champ |
| 76% | CAREW | 5 | Seven-time A.L. batting champ |
| 73% | CAREW | 5 | Seven-time A.L. batting champ Rod |
| 73% | CAREW | 5 | Seven-time A.L. batting champ Rod ___ |
| 73% | ODOUL | 5 | Two-time N.L. batting champ Lefty |
| 73% | MCGEE | 5 | Two-time N.L. batting champ Willie |
| 69% | ALOU | 4 | N.L. batting champ of 1966 |
| 69% | ALOU | 4 | 1966 N.L. batting champ |
| 67% | CLEMENTE | 8 | N.L. batting champ, 1964, '65 and '67 |
| 66% | RODMAN | 6 | Seven-time N.B.A. rebounding champ, 1992-98 |
| 66% | GARR | 4 | 1974 N.L. batting champ Ralph |
| 66% | ANDRES | 6 | 1993 N.L. batting champ Galarraga |
| 66% | ALOU | 4 | 1966 N.L. batting champ Matty |
| 66% | SOTO | 4 | 2020 N.L. batting champ Juan |
| 63% | GARR | 4 | Ralph ___, 1974 N.L. batting champ |
| 62% | OLIVA | 5 | Three-time A.L. batting champ |
| 62% | BRETT | 5 | Three-time A.L. batting champ |
| 62% | BOGGS | 5 | Five-time A.L. batting champ |
| 61% | GWYNN | 5 | Tony who led the N.L. in batting eight times |
| 60% | KINER | 5 | Seven-time N.L. home run king Ralph |
| 59% | CAREW | 5 | Rod who was a seven-time A.L. batting champ |
| 59% | GARR | 4 | Ralph who was the 1974 N.L. batting champ |
| 58% | OLIVA | 5 | Three-time A.L. batting champ Tony |
| 57% | OTT | 3 | Six-time N.L. home run champ |
| 56% | REYES | 5 | Three-time N.L. stolen base champ José |
| 56% | OTT | 3 | Six-time N.L. home run champ Mel |
| 55% | BROWNS | 6 | Seven-time N.F.L. East champions in the 1950's |
| 55% | AVILA | 5 | 1954 A.L. batting champ |