| 100% | ODIE | 4 | Pet whose original owner was Lyman, in "Garfield" |
| 39% | VOLLEYBALL | 10 | Ball game invented by William G Morgan whose original name in the late 19th century was Mintonette |
| 38% | MAGNACARTA | 10 | Document whose original version was annulled by the Pope the same year it was adopted, in 1215 |
| 36% | REMBRANDT | 9 | ___ van Rijn, Dutch painter whose painting "The Adoration of the Magi" was confirmed to be original in 2021 |
| 35% | CAT | 3 | Pet whose exposed tummy might be a trap |
| 35% | MUTTS | 5 | Pets whose owners might have their DNA analyzed |
| 35% | SNAKE | 5 | Pet whose nickname might be Fang? |
| 35% | SULK | 4 | Be in a pet |
| 35% | SHARON | 6 | Israeli prime minister born in Palestine whose original surname was Scheinermann |
| 34% | GUINEAPIG | 9 | Pet whose name is also an unwitting test subject |
| 34% | CAT | 3 | Pet whose whiskers are about as wide as its body |
| 34% | EDDIEMONEY | 10 | Rock singer whose original last name was Mahoney |
| 34% | JON | 3 | Garfield's owner, in the comics |
| 34% | JON | 3 | Garfield's owner, in the funnies |
| 34% | ALI | 3 | Boxer whose original surname was Clay |
| 33% | CUNARD | 6 | Samuel ___, who got the first British transatlantic steamship mail contract in 1839 and whose company is now owned by the Carnival Corporation |
| 33% | ANDY | 4 | Woody's original owner in the "Toy Story" films |
| 33% | PAM | 3 | "The Office" character whose original last name was Beesly |
| 33% | METS | 4 | Baseball team whose original full name is rarely used |
| 33% | IVORYSOAP | 9 | Product whose original slogan was "It floats" |
| 33% | MRT | 3 | Actor whose original name was Laurence Tureaud |
| 32% | STYX | 4 | 1970s-1980s band whose original lead singer was Dennis DeYoung |
| 32% | LEK | 3 | Coin whose original portrait was Alexander the Great |
| 32% | POPTARTS | 8 | Product whose original mascot was Milton the Toaster |
| 32% | GOLDFISH | 8 | Pet Klaus is this animal in American Dad! |
| 32% | LBJ | 3 | Prez whose library is in Austin |
| 32% | NUN | 3 | One whose life is in order? |
| 32% | TRENT | 5 | River whose source is in Staffordshire |
| 32% | DANE | 4 | Whose house might be in Aarhus |