| 100% | ARMS | 4 | Shiva is often pictured with four |
| 49% | ARMS | 4 | The goddess Kali is often depicted with four of these limbs |
| 48% | ARMS | 4 | The Hindu god Ganesha is often depicted with four of them |
| 45% | SWAMI | 5 | Person often pictured with crossed legs |
| 44% | FABIO | 5 | Icon often pictured with wind-blown hair |
| 43% | ERATO | 5 | Goddess often pictured with a crown of roses |
| 43% | WIZARDHAT | 9 | Pointed headgear often pictured with stars and moons |
| 41% | {QUARTER}NOTES | 14 | There are often four to a measure |
| 41% | ONEC | 4 | What "accommodate" is often inaccurately spelled with |
| 40% | GOATEE | 6 | Satan is often seen with one |
| 40% | ORDERBLANK | 10 | Payment is often sent with one |
| 40% | HALO | 4 | Buddha is often depicted with one |
| 40% | ROOTBEERS | 9 | Floats are often made with them |
| 40% | FANGS | 5 | Gargoyles are often depicted with them |
| 39% | HANDLE | 6 | Fragile packages are often marked "__ with care" |
| 39% | ALES | 4 | These are often drawn with big heads |
| 39% | AUK | 3 | Great ___, extinct bird that is often wrongly associated with penguins |
| 38% | RELAY | 5 | With 5-Down, it often has four legs |
| 38% | EGGS | 4 | Meats are often paired with them at breakfast |
| 38% | SHAIVISM | 8 | Hindu denomination with supreme being Shiva |
| 38% | POPPYSEEDS | 10 | What rolls are often topped with |
| 38% | TARPAULIN | 9 | Covering whose name is often shortened to its first four letters |
| 37% | GOATEE | 6 | The devil is often depicted with one |
| 37% | PITA | 4 | Bread that is often served with hummus |
| 37% | RUM | 3 | Alcohol which is often paired with coke |
| 37% | TRINIDAD | 8 | Country that is often paired with Tobago |
| 37% | OREO | 4 | Cookie that is often paired with milk |
| 37% | TEA | 3 | Beverage that is often enjoyed with scones |
| 37% | ZEALAND | 7 | Maori people are often associated with New __ |
| 37% | OATS | 4 | Grains that are often mixed with honey |