| 100% | KOOPA | 5 | Super Mario creature that resembles a turtle |
| 55% | HARE | 4 | Creature that resembles a rabbit |
| 53% | EEL | 3 | Ocean creature that resembles a snake |
| 52% | ENT | 3 | Tolkien creature that resembles a 56-Across |
| 50% | EWOK | 4 | "Return of the Jedi" creature that resembles a teddy bear |
| 47% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario Bros. character who resembles a mushroom |
| 44% | EWOK | 4 | Furry "Star Wars" creature that some say resembles a Shih Tzu |
| 42% | EWOK | 4 | Creature from "Star Wars" that resembles a teddy bear |
| 41% | OREO | 4 | Cookie that introduced a Super Mario edition in 2023 |
| 39% | EEL | 3 | Fish that resembles a snake |
| 39% | ELK | 3 | Animal that resembles a reindeer |
| 39% | HARE | 4 | Animal that resembles a rabbit |
| 39% | TOAD | 4 | Animal that resembles a frog |
| 39% | COATI | 5 | Animal that resembles a raccoon |
| 39% | LEEK | 4 | Vegetable that resembles a scallion |
| 39% | MESH | 4 | Fabric that resembles a net |
| 39% | ANT | 3 | Insect that resembles a termite |
| 39% | FROG | 4 | Animal that resembles a toad |
| 39% | AXE | 3 | Tool that resembles a hatchet |
| 39% | GNAT | 4 | Insect that resembles a mosquito |
| 39% | EEL | 3 | Fish that resembles a serpent |
| 39% | CANOE | 5 | Boat that resembles a kayak |
| 39% | BANANA | 6 | Fruit that resembles a plantain |
| 39% | CARREL | 6 | Desk that resembles a cubicle |
| 39% | CROW | 4 | Bird that resembles a raven |
| 39% | APE | 3 | Primate that resembles a human |
| 39% | ACAI | 4 | Berry that resembles a grape |
| 39% | ALOE | 4 | Succulent that resembles a cactus |
| 39% | BUTTE | 5 | Hill that resembles a mesa |
| 39% | CICADA | 6 | Insect that resembles a locust |