| 100% | KOOPA | 5 | Turtle-like creature from the Mario universe |
| 52% | PIXIES | 6 | Fairy-like creatures from the English countryside |
| 52% | SMURF | 5 | Small blue human-like creature from the movies |
| 48% | YETI | 4 | Creature from the Himalayas |
| 48% | EWE | 3 | Creature from the west |
| 48% | EWES | 4 | Creatures from the west |
| 46% | EWOK | 4 | Creature from the forest moon of Endor |
| 46% | LAGOON | 6 | Creature from the Black __, 1954 horror film |
| 46% | SWAMPMONSTER | 12 | Creature from the Black Lagoon, e.g. |
| 46% | YETI | 4 | Mythical creature from the Himalayas |
| 45% | GOLLUM | 6 | Creature from The Hobbit who loves his "precious" |
| 45% | YETI | 4 | Giant mythical creature from the Himalayas |
| 45% | LAGOON | 6 | 1954 film, Creature from the Black __ |
| 44% | SOLAR | 5 | Like energy from the sun |
| 44% | PASTEURIZED | 11 | Like milk from the grocery |
| 44% | ORC | 3 | Villainous creature from The Lord of the Rings |
| 44% | ENT | 3 | Fantasy creature from the Old English for "giant" |
| 43% | OLD | 3 | Like something from the Jurassic period |
| 43% | SEXY | 4 | Like Sadie from The Beatles song |
| 43% | INFRARED | 8 | Like radiation from the Big Bang |
| 43% | ETS | 3 | Creatures from across the galaxy: Abbr. |
| 43% | FAUN | 4 | Creature from the Spyro Reignited Trilogy video game released last year |
| 43% | DAISY | 5 | Princess in the Mario universe named for a flower |
| 43% | ORC | 3 | Brutish, evil creature from The Lord of the Rings |
| 43% | ALF | 3 | 1980s sitcom about a creature from the planet Melmac |
| 43% | MAP | 3 | Marauder's ___ from the "Harry Potter" universe |
| 42% | VAST | 4 | Like the universe |
| 42% | ORC | 3 | Goblin-like creature of a race from "The Lord of the Rings" |
| 42% | BADKARMA | 8 | Wrongdoer's consequence from the universe |
| 42% | OGRE | 4 | Giant from the fables like "Shrek" |